Disclaimer these are my “opinions” based on my system synergy and my listening room.
The NC500 REV D sounded like shit for the first 45 minutes. Came into their own after about 2 hours. No major noticeable changes after.
Rev D are more rounder with more presence. More detail retrieval without sounding more detailed. Bombastic bass, same music cut things rattle and shake that don’t with the 1200as.
1200as more lean but not thin. Great bass but not as authoritative as the Rev D. Excellent amps with a more “airy” presence.
Both amps are amazing in their own right. I could easily live with either.
Amps of comparison from memory are the REF 75 with KT150, Rogue ST100, custom Scott Nixon tube/fet hybrids. All still in my possession.