I'm leaving high end audio...

I agree with the substance of what you say, but that was not the point I was making. My approach to system building, as anyone would see from my system, is substantially different from the objectivists. I'm arguing for basic civility in our discussions. The fact that we have differences of opinion about a hobby does not make either side stupid or idiots or nitwits. It just means we have different opinions. Once we start calling each other names, the meaningful discussion is over which, to my understanding, is the whole point of a forum. I think that sort of thing also inhibits folks who are newer to the hobby from participating. Just my thought and I'm not and I know there are times that I need to take my own advice. There is a basic rule of advocacy-if you are debating an issue, attack the substance, not the person. Of course, its the internet and everyone is free to say whatever they please.

While I generally agree with you, there are some people that are just nitwits and deserve to be called nitwits.

An example, I had someone post on my photo I identified as my work bench "that may have originally been your workbench but don't lie to people, that has definitely gone through a layer of stolen fake Al slop treatments. We aren't stupid."

I called him a nitwit and posted the original photo before I boosted the colors to adjust for shadows and colors to prove I don't lie and the photo's I claim I took are real.

While it sounds good in make-believe world to never call someone an idiot. Sometimes that is the right response.

Original and the one I adjusted colors on below as reference:

orig.jpg

Greek Audio Geek Restoration Workshop.png
 
Last edited:
While I generally agree with you, there are some people that are just nitwits and deserve to be called nitwits.

An example, I had someone post on my photo I identified as my work bench "that may have originally been your workbench but don't lie to people, that has definitely gone through a layer of stolen fake Al slop treatments. We aren't stupid."

I called him a nitwit and posted the original photo before I boosted the colors to adjust for shadows and colors to prove I don't like and the photo's I claim I took are real.

While it sounds good in make-believe world to never call someone an idiot. Sometimes that is the right response.

Original and the one I adjusted colors on below as reference:

View attachment 36404

View attachment 36405
Some people are just flipping stupid sometimes. Why would anyone fake their work bench? That is just idiotic on it's basic level to accuse someone of.
 
Some people are just flipping stupid sometimes. Why would anyone fake their work bench? That is just idiotic on it's basic level to accuse someone of.

And to make it even more stupid, he was one of those people who when you check their profile have as there 'about' some crap about how we all need to be nice to people. LOL
 
While I agree that such a position betrays ignorance on the part of those who deny the efficacy of components such as ICs, PCs, dacs (and even amps? Are you kidding?) to those who actually have considerable real-world experience and who recognize just how myopic that entire ideology really is, I have to wonder why you’d bother to contest the point with that crowd. It strikes me as akin to preaching non-violence at the Coliseum when Caesar and the spectators just want to see someone get eaten.

Because I can't stand to see false information given to people asking for help choosing gear as they have no experience. There was one guy who upgraded to a $2000 TT and was asking about phono preamps and another guy said a Schiit Skoll F is all you need and that above the $400 price point there is no difference in phono preamps. He said that has been proven, LOL. I called him out and he became snarky, belittling, and was posting all this data to support him. He was an ASR guy of course. He said the differences I heard with my Gold Note PH-10, Darlington Labs MP8B and my Vista phono 2 were all in my head and expectation bias and my ears were wrong. Where the FK do these guys come from.
 
Last edited:
I have a different approach to audio than the ASR folks. I definitely hear a difference between dacs and amps, etc. But it’s just a difference of opinion. they have as much right to their point of view as we do. No reason to make it personal. It’s just listening to music.
ASR consistently derides and insults those who claim they can hear differences regardless of measurements. If they refuse to use their hearing to assist them in discovering potential sonic differences and demean and call those people that do dillusionary, what is the basis for their point of view?

Oh I get it. Their eyes, using measurement devices, are better than their ears in determing sound quality. Everyone knows you hear by using your eyes.

Definition of "stupid". Lacking intelligence, common sense, or clear thinking judgement.
 
Last edited:
ASR consistently derides and insults those who claim they can hear differences regardless of measurements. If they refuse to use their hearing to assist them in discovering potential sonic differences and demean and call those people that do dillusionary, what is the basis for their point of view?

Oh I get it. Their eyes, using measurement devices, are better than their ears in determing sound quality. Everyone knows you hear by using your eyes.

Definition of "stupid". Lacking intelligence, common sense, or clear thinking judgement.
I understand and have been on the receiving end of some of the ASR stuff. I'd just say that I made a living arguing cases for 40 plus yeas and learned early on that ad hominem attacks, even if responding in kind, never makes you right, never makes you sound smarter and always degrades the discussion. It can make you feel better in the moment-I'm as susceptible to that as the next guy. And I understand that hoping for civility on internet forums is a lot like trying to walk between rain drops, but maybe Rodney King had a point. Just a shallow thought.
 
I understand and have been on the receiving end of some of the ASR stuff. I'd just say that I made a living arguing cases for 40 plus yeas and learned early on that ad hominem attacks, even if responding in kind, never makes you right, never makes you sound smarter and always degrades the discussion.
I called them stupid. Words ASR has consistently used this word (or equivalent) when dicussing those who use their ears versus measuremenrts to judge sound quality on the subjective / objective discussion. And ASR is not going to change their position.

I trust / hope you are not condoning understanding and neutrality regarding the Rodney King incident. If you are, I have nothing to say. I am way too angry. Remember the riot in Los Angeles in 1992 caused by the trial verdict.

And you are not trying to walk between rain drops. Try a hailstorm.
 
Last edited:
I called them stupid. Words ASR has used this word when dicussing those who use their ears versus measuremenrts to judge sound quality on the subjective / objective discussion. And ASR is not going to change their position

I trust / hope you are not condoning understanding and neutrality regarding the Rodney King incident. If you are, I have nothing to say. I am way too angry.

And you are not trying to walk between rain drops. Try a hailstorm.
Im just suggesting that the forum experience might be better with a little more civility. Particularly for newcomers. Nothing more than that.

Not trying to trigger your anger. You are free to disagree, and it seems that you do. As I said, I realize that hoping for civility on the internet is a lost cause.
 
Im just suggesting that the forum experience might be better with a little more civility. Particularly for newcomers. Nothing more than that.

Not trying to trigger your anger. You are free to disagree, and it seems that you do. As I said, I realize that hoping for civility on the internet is a lost cause.

The dude doesn't abide.
 
Hi Kramer64. Thanks for your civility efforts. Sounds like you want unlimited dialogue with everyone understanding the other sides perspective regardless of how wrong the other person's opinions are. At some point, one has to say no, you are wrong. The polite phrase is something like "I respectfully disagree with your opinion". World discourse is not a venue for perpetual arbitration. Great thought but you are asking for total civility and respect. Given human nature, It may be the ideal but is impossible to attain be it a forum or anywhere else where competing points of view exist.
 
Last edited:
This thread is a click magnet. Next....

It probably did start out that way but it evolved into a pretty good discussion IMO. I suppose when a thread goes for 8 pages there's eventually going to be some friction, LOL In fact, on one of the prior pages Michael comments on how civil the thread was going. It just takes some effort as Kramer64 points out.
 
It probably did start out that way but it evolved into a pretty good discussion IMO. I suppose when a thread goes for 8 pages there's eventually going to be some friction, LOL In fact, on one of the prior pages Michael comments on how civil the thread was going. It just takes some effort as Kramer64 points out.

I agree. This has been a post that has covered a variety of topics with everyone being calm and cordial.

If this thread doesn't interest someone, I respect that. No one is being forced to read it.

For the rest of us I think it's been a positive posting and reading experience.

At the end of the day isn't that the purpose of ANY thread - to get people to click on comment on it?
 
Last edited:
To get back to the original point of this thread...

I feel STRONGER about what I wrote than ever.

Especially after seeing a Facebook post today lecturing audio influencers about financial transparency, even quoting federal law about disclosing relationships with manufacturers, distributors, and sponsors.

YET...

That same person is a co-owner of a forum that accepts sponsorship money from audio companies, including brands whose products and business interests are discussed and promoted on that very forum and by him.

Where's the same transparency about those financial relationships?

To be clear, I'm ALL FOR financial transparency. And there's nothing inherently wrong with accepting sponsorship money.

But I believe leading by example is a whole lot more meaningful than lecturing everyone else.

And THIS, my friends, is exactly the sort of nonsense I was talking about in my article about leaving traditional high-end audio behind.

The sponsorships. The gatekeeping. The egos. The endless drama. The double standards.

They are so mired in it themselves they can't even see how polluted much of it has become.

It's much nicer being on the side of music and audio friends than those in that pay-for-play game.

All just my own personal opinions and I'm not accusing nor implying anything illegal or unethical by anyone. Just saying people need to walk their own talk.
 
Last edited:
To get back to the original point of this thread...

I feel STRONGER about what I wrote than ever.

Especially after seeing a Facebook post today from someone lecturing audio influencers about financial transparency, even quoting federal law about disclosing relationships with manufacturers, distributors, and sponsors.

YET...

That same person is a co-owner of a forum that accepts sponsorship money from audio companies, including brands whose products and business interests are discussed and promoted on that very forum and by him.

Where's the same transparency about those financial relationships?

Who's paying the forum? How much? And what, exactly, do those sponsorship dollars buy?

Advertising? Promotional posts? Pinned threads? Special treatment?

These are perfectly reasonable questions when someone is publicly demanding transparency from everybody else.

To be clear, I'm ALL FOR financial transparency. And there's nothing inherently wrong with accepting sponsorship money.

But I believe leading by example is a whole lot more meaningful than lecturing everyone else.

And THIS, my friends, is exactly the sort of nonsense I was talking about in my article about leaving traditional high-end audio behind.

The sponsorships. The gatekeeping. The egos. The endless drama. The double standards.

They are so mired in it themselves they can't even see how polluted much of it has become.

It's much nicer being on the side of music and audio friends than those in that pay-for-play game.

All just my own personal opinions.
Link the post.

I agree about the concept. But as I noted earlier, anyone buying that stuff. Your rich enough and educated enough to know what your getting. You probably sat in a store, like the look and the sound. Its not like your dealing with a necessity like Health Care. Its excessive income build up our wanting to spend before you die. Audio is your hobby. So why not indulge.

I blew good money on a AMG GLE53 Merceses. It cost more than a stereo!!!!!!! Its a bunch of hype. Gosh darn fun the drive. I assume the whole of the reviews are bloated fluff. I know the Porsche Cayene GTS would have performed better. And a basic EV would cost way less and be more affordable to own. But I bought the Mercedes anyways.
 
Hey Kingrex. Nice car. Life must be good in retirement. You just lost your right to complain about audio prices. :) 0 to 60? Miles on gas and electric / total mileage range? How quick does it regarge at charging station and home garage? Best.
 
Last edited:
Interesting times.

I don’t care what goodies someone gets from vendors or who promotes which products. It’s just basic honesty, however, for anyone reviewing a product to disclose anything of value- money, discounts, gifts, loans, etc., from the vendor or its competitors. The FTC rules simply codify what we already know about honest behavior.

At this point there are all sorts of claims, allegations and innuendo concerning YouTubers, forums and other reviewers in the hifi world. I don’t know whats true but the whole shanby business is unfortunate and unnecessary-I hope anyone who engages in deception is held accountable.

As to WBF, I certainly have no way to know its internal workings. I’m not an owner, sponsor or a member of the exalted golden ear audio class. I see, however, that WBF discloses its sponsors and its sponsored threads. If that’s a full disclosure, I think that’s all we can expect. We can all decide for ourselves from that point.

I also agree that consumers would be wise to take it all with a grain of salt. There are a few YouTubers that offer meaningful information- Analogholics for example, there are others that can be entertaining but shouldn’t be taken seriously. Most just seem desperate for clicks and attention/ no problem with that if all the conflicts are disclosed. Not all consumers are discerning, however, and the fact that someone is gullible doesn’t make it right or legal to deceive them.

Interesting times.
 
As to WBF, I certainly have no way to know its internal workings. I’m not an owner, sponsor or a member of the exalted golden ear audio class. I see, however, that WBF discloses its sponsors and its sponsored threads. If that’s a full disclosure, I think that’s all we can expect. We can all decide for ourselves from that point.

But here's the problem with your assumption.

Simply identifying sponsors on a page doesn't necessarily tell readers the full nature of the financial relationships or what those sponsorship dollars buy.

Does sponsorship include paid posting to generate the appearance of interest in a product? Special treatment of threads? Promotional activity beyond clearly labeled advertising?

And what about the people running the forum? Have any received free or discounted equipment, or other benefits, from brands whose products they publicly discuss or promote? Are the owners compensated for the threads they start talking about gear in their home?

How about when the owners then move to social media and post in defense of there sponsors with no disclosure on those posts or videos they are receiving money or other from the company?

And are you sure ALL the people paying to be able to post are disclosed?

Do you know the answers to any of those questions?


Because if you don't, how can you honestly and thoughtfully conclude that the disclosures are complete?

I'm not suggesting anything illegal has occurred. I'm asking reasonable questions about transparency, especially when people associated with a commercially sponsored forum are publicly lecturing others about disclosure.

Transparency should work both ways, shouldn't it?

And respectfully, assuming everything has been disclosed simply because there's a sponsor which is assumed to be complete list seems a little...well.....

And here's the good news. My attorneys intend to pursue relevant communications, contracts, financial relationships, and other records through the legal process.

So rather than speculate about what these sponsorship arrangements involve, we may have an opportunity to examine the actual documents and establish the facts.

Transparency is a wonderful thing, isn't it? 😉
 
Back
Top