In 1936, Shostakovich fell from official favour. The year began with a series of attacks on him in
Pravda, in particular an article entitled, "Muddle Instead of Music". Shostakovich was away on a concert tour in
Arkhangelsk when he heard news of the first
Pravda article. Two days before the article was published on the evening of 28 January,[SUP]
[16][/SUP] a friend had advised Shostakovich to attend the
Bolshoi Theatre production of
Lady Macbeth. When he arrived, he saw that
Joseph Stalin and the
Politburo were there. In letters written to his friend
Ivan Sollertinsky, Shostakovich recounted the horror with which he watched as Stalin shuddered every time the brass and percussion played too loudly. Equally horrifying was the way Stalin and his companions laughed at the love-making scene between Sergei and Katerina. Eyewitness accounts testify that Shostakovich was "white as a sheet" when he went to take his bow after the third act.[SUP]
[17][/SUP]
The article condemned
Lady Macbeth as formalist, "coarse, primitive and vulgar".[SUP]
[18][/SUP] Consequently, commissions began to fall off, and his income fell by about three quarters. Even Soviet music critics who had praised the opera were forced to recant in print, saying they "failed to detect the shortcomings of
Lady Macbeth as pointed out by
Pravda".[SUP]
[19][/SUP] Shortly after the "Muddle Instead of Music" article,
Pravda published another, "Ballet Falsehood," that criticized Shostakovich’s ballet
The Limpid Stream. Shostakovich did not expect this second article because the general public and press already accepted this music as "democratic" - that is, tuneful and accessible. However,
Pravda criticized
The Limpid Stream for incorrectly displaying peasant life on the collective farm.[SUP]
[20][/SUP]
More widely, 1936 marked the beginning of the
Great Terror, in which many of the composer's friends and relatives were imprisoned or killed: these included his patron
Marshal Tukhachevsky (shot months after his arrest); his brother-in-law
Vsevolod Frederiks (a distinguished physicist, who was eventually released but died before he got home); his close friend
Nikolai Zhilyayev (a musicologist who had taught Tukhachevsky; shot shortly after his arrest); his mother-in-law, the astronomer Sofiya Mikhaylovna Varzar (sent to a camp in
Karaganda); his friend the Marxist writer Galina Serebryakova (20 years in camps); his uncle Maxim Kostrykin (died); and his colleagues
Boris Kornilov and
Adrian Piotrovsky (executed).[SUP]
[21][/SUP] His only consolation in this period was the birth of his daughter Galina in 1936; his son
Maxim was born two years later.