Dedicated purpose built listening spaces

BendingWave

Active member
Joined
Oct 27, 2017
Messages
276
Location
Boca Raton Florida
I was wondering how many of the posters here have
1) dedicated listening space
2) treated listening room
3) have had professional setup or assistance in their system
4) did it all themselves in a common family space
 
I have a treated room. It is not purpose built for listening, but is not a shared space and is used only for listening, if that makes sense. I'm interested in hiring a pro to optimize the setup, just nor sure how to locate the right person and have no idea what a fair price is for that service.
 
I have a treated room. It is not purpose built for listening, but is not a shared space and is used only for listening, if that makes sense. I'm interested in hiring a pro to optimize the setup, just nor sure how to locate the right person and have no idea what a fair price is for that service.
thank you for the reply. There are a few people that do such services. I of course know nothing about your gear, room and goals as those should be defined in advance before you hire someone. I do think that there should be more available information for people to at least get themselves started in the proper direction and it might be a project for me this summer. I am not interested in traveling to set up stuff I didn't sell ( too old ) however there are available services.
I believe you will be very pleased if you hire someone qualified>
 
thank you for the reply. There are a few people that do such services. I of course know nothing about your gear, room and goals as those should be defined in advance before you hire someone. I do think that there should be more available information for people to at least get themselves started in the proper direction and it might be a project for me this summer. I am not interested in traveling to set up stuff I didn't sell ( too old ) however there are available services.
I believe you will be very pleased if you hire someone qualified>
I've read about Mr. Trayle, who is apparently very talented. t would be interesting if someone could start a list of qualified folks who provide this service and their location. Seems like it would be money well spent.
 
I had a 9.5 x 14 room in my prior house. Treatments were necessary. I did REW measurements, and consulted via email with GIK acoustics. Large corner bass absorbers, another panel for the back wall.

I have moved, and new room is still a work in progress, but the treatments came with me. As the bass mode is 50 hz in the new room vs the 40hz of the old room, the treatments appear to be even better suited to this room. The bass traps actually work on 50hz. The 40hz would have taken many, tuned, 2x2 foot panels about 10 inches deep, like a whole wall of them.
 
1, 2 & 3. I have a dedicated music room. Was planned and executed during the construction of our retirement home. It is acoustically treated (actually reduced some after the purchase of the MBL 101s) with dedicated power and with carefully planned HVAC system for noise avoidance. I’ve had some professional setup assistance.
 
Finding a qualified person is not easy. Lots of people say they can but they can't. They are just learning off you. Going to the manufactures of the product is probably a good start. I have one in the Toronto area.
Anyone having any ideas on qualified people or how to vet them please pipe up.
 
1, 2, and 3 for me also.
Came about 15 years ago when my wife, who has put up with my audio issue for 52 years suggested I take our sunroom and build a listening room with the space.
 
I am currently building a dedicated private cinema / 2 channel listening space. I designed the space for both 2 channel and immersive multichannel audio. The all-tube 2 channel system will be electrically isolated from the theater system. It is very tricky to design for both, and there are always compromises. The outcome will be dependent on how well I manage the compromises.

For immersive audio, the system will be Dolby Atmos focused and 9.4.6 This is the 15 speaker system described on page 148 of RP-22 with the addition of 4 subwoofers. For those not familiar with the lingo, that's 9 'bed layer' speakers : L, C, R, and two more wide screen wall speakers and 4 surround speakers, 9 total. Then 4 individually driven subwoofers and 6 Atoms height speakers. Thus 9.4.6. That's 19 discrete channels of audio.

I am designing the system to CTA RP-22:


I am shooting for Level 3 performance, which is extremely difficult to pull off.

Level 4 is the rarified atmosphere of professional private cinema at the $5,000,000 and up price point.

2. I have taken senior level acoustical courses at university and own a MLSSA acoustical measurement system. I will DIY with professional help as needed. I will work with an acoustical materials supplier because figuring out the placement, size, and depth/# of cycles of diffusers requires computer software I don't have.

The room will be acoustically treated to achieve a balanced Rdt of 0.5 sec down to 100 Hz. Rdt will rise below that because it is almost impossible to add enough LF absorption to a normal room. I plan on using Trinnov Spherical Waveforming with 4 identical subwoofers symmetrically placed to reduce Rdt below 100 Hz. The rear subs are delayed and phase inverted to cancel the plane wave coming from the front.

To avoid over-damping the room at high frequencies, I will use an incremental approach to room treatment:
Design > implement > test > repeat.

3. For video, I will hire a professional calibrator who knows JVC projectors and has invested in the tens of thousands of dollars in spectrophotometers and spectroradiometers required to do an accurate calibration. If I find I'm not getting the audio performance I need, there are two professional audio calibrators that specialize in Trinnov systems. I won't hesitate to cry uncle and hire help.

The room is getting close to completion. Drywall is up and painted.
 
I was wondering how many of the posters here have
1) dedicated listening space
2) treated listening room
3) have had professional setup or assistance in their system
4) did it all themselves in a common family space

#1, #2, and #3 for me. Excellent measurements in RT60 and RTA but more importantly music sounds lifelike.
 
1 & 2

My wife was so happy when we bought our house to put me in the lower level with my system, LOL I did compromise by putting home theater in there as well. It doesn't get used so much anymore.

I use treatment and set the panels around the room by ear. I also placed my speakers by ear.

If you hire someone you should vet them and make sure they know what you have. A friend flew someone out to his house, from what I gather he tried but was clearly out of his element with this system. My friend ended up putting everything basically back the way it was before the guy came out

I will say a person needs to experiment with system placement in their room. Rules of thumb or rules in general are a nice start but don't work for everyone. AS an example, when my speakers were delivered the dealer set them up with toe in. Once I got to playing around with them I find I prefer very little toe in. The horns are large, wide, they just image better in my room with less toe in, according to me.
 
Back
Top