Considering Tobian 15FH (Among Others)

PHX-SQ2

New member
Joined
Jan 8, 2021
Messages
24
Location
Oregon
I favor the vintage JBL sound, specifically the models using horn-loaded compression drivers. One of my prized possessions is a pristine pair of JBL L300 Summit (circa 1980). I play them in a medium-sized room decked out with Acoustic Sciences Corporation (ASC) treatments. The sound is punchy, thrilling, and vivid.

I have a separate, larger (28x17x9) room that I also use for audio. Currently, I use Audio Physic Cardeas in that room. They sound beautiful and can pressurize the room, but after loads of experimenting with placement and electronics, I’ve determined that they lack the impact and punch that I crave.

My sense is that the room needs speakers with big-ass woofers of a relatively high sensitivity to excite the air (i.e., to deliver the kind of punch that you feel in your ankles and belly). For clarity, while performance in the sub-bass region is important to me, I prioritize performance in the upper bass and lower midrange regions (60-250 Hz).

I’m consuming info about several speakers that may fit the bill. I plan on traveling, if necessary, to hear them. The Tobian 15FH is one of them. I’ve had a few phone conversations with Mike at Suncoast Audio, which is the U.S. distributor (and seller) of Tobian products. Mike has been very helpful, including by directing my focus among the Tobian speaker models considering my affection for the vintage JBL sound.

Speakers I’m considering:
- Tobian 15FH
- O Audio Verdande
- JBL K2 S9900 (used)
- JBL Summit Makalu
- Volti Audio Rival
- Vandersteen KENTO Carbon (outlier but I’ve owned and loved Vandersteen)

I acknowledge that the price range is wide. All the speakers are highly competent, I suspect. I’m wiling to spend for exhilaration.

So, forum members, lay it on me. Do you think I’m on the right track toward vintage-JBL-ish sound in a relatively large room? I’m highly attracted to the Tobian design and aesthetic , so it would be great to receive feedback from Tobian speaker owners.
 
Last edited:
YES YES YES YES!!!

I have had DOZENS of speakers come through here.

What did I spend my money on to purchase? Tobian's.

I first had the 12's then upgraded to the 15's as I have a very large room.

I will only say this: they require 400 hours breaking AND they require you being dedicated to spending the time to place them properly.

I've spent about 30+++ hours experimenting with set up for them both and can help you dial them in quickly.

If you do spend the time, they are a supremely musical speaker that can make take you to a place - where for me - no speaker regardless of price has ever been able to achieve.

The JBL's are excellent indeed. But they don't (IMO) offer the musical engagement the Tobian's do.

Literally if you told me you would replace my Tobians for free with any speaker in the world at any price, other than maybe vintage old RCA's from the 1930's or old Altec's, I would not take you up on that offer.
 
I favor the vintage JBL sound, specifically the models using horn-loaded compression drivers. One of my prized possessions is a pristine pair of JBL L300 Summit (circa 1980). I play them in a medium-sized room decked out with Acoustic Sciences Corporation (ASC) treatments. The sound is punchy, thrilling, and vivid.

I have a separate, larger (28x17x9) room that I also use for audio. Currently, I use Audio Physic Cardeas in that room. They sound beautiful and can pressurize the room, but after loads of experimenting with placement and electronics, I’ve determined that they lack the impact and punch that I crave.

My sense is that the room needs speakers with big-ass woofers of a relatively high sensitivity to excite the air (i.e., to deliver the kind of punch that you feel in your ankles and belly). For clarity, while performance in the sub-bass region is important to me, I prioritize performance in the upper bass and lower midrange regions (60-250 Hz).

I’m consuming info about several speakers that may fit the bill. I plan on traveling, if necessary, to hear them. The Tobian 15FH is one of them. I’ve had a few phone conversations with Mike at Suncoast Audio, which is the U.S. distributor (and seller) of Tobian products. Mike has been very helpful, including by directing my focus among the Tobian speaker models considering my affection for the vintage JBL sound.

Speakers I’m considering:
- Tobian 15FH
- O Audio Verdande
- JBL K2 S9900 (used)
- JBL Summit Makalu
- Volti Audio Rival
- Vandersteen KENTO Carbon (outlier but I’ve owned and loved Vandersteen)

I acknowledge that the price range is wide. All the speakers are highly competent, I suspect. I’m wiling to spend for exhilaration.

So, forum members, lay it on me. Do you think I’m on the right track toward vintage-JBL-ish sound in a relatively large room? I’m highly attracted to the Tobian design and aesthetic , so it would be great to receive feedback from Tobian speaker owners.

If you love the sound of vintage JBL speakers, try and find a pair of JBL 4345s.
 
YES YES YES YES!!!

I have had DOZENS of speakers come through here.

What did I spend my money on to purchase? Tobian's.

I first had the 12's then upgraded to the 15's as I have a very large room.

I will only say this: they require 400 hours breaking AND they require you being dedicated to spending the time to place them properly.

I've spent about 30+++ hours experimenting with set up for them both and can help you dial them in quickly.

If you do spend the time, they are a supremely musical speaker that can make take you to a place - where for me - no speaker regardless of price has ever been able to achieve.

The JBL's are excellent indeed. But they don't (IMO) offer the musical engagement the Tobian's do.

Literally if you told me you would replace my Tobians for free with any speaker in the world at any price, other than maybe vintage old RCA's from the 1930's or old Altec's, I would not take you up on that offer.

YES YES YES YES!!!

I have had DOZENS of speakers come through here.

What did I spend my money on to purchase? Tobian's.

I first had the 12's then upgraded to the 15's as I have a very large room.

I will only say this: they require 400 hours breaking AND they require you being dedicated to spending the time to place them properly.

I've spent about 30+++ hours experimenting with set up for them both and can help you dial them in quickly.

If you do spend the time, they are a supremely musical speaker that can make take you to a place - where for me - no speaker regardless of price has ever been able to achieve.

The JBL's are excellent indeed. But they don't (IMO) offer the musical engagement the Tobian's do.

Literally if you told me you would replace my Tobians for free with any speaker in the world at any price, other than maybe vintage old RCA's from the 1930's or old Altec's, I would not take you up on that offer. feedback - thank you.
Thank you for the pertinent feedback!

I realize that “punch” is a bit cliche in audio, but I presume that you have an appreciation for what I seek. Do you believe that the Tobian FH speakers deliver the JBL-like punch, assuming proper placement in the room?
 
If you love the sound of vintage JBL speakers, try and find a pair of JBL 4345s.
Great recommendation for achieving the sound I want. However, for the subject room, I want a speaker with a more attractive (to me) facade.
 
Thank you for the pertinent feedback!

I realize that “punch” is a bit cliche in audio, but I presume that you have an appreciation for what I seek. Do you believe that the Tobian FH speakers deliver the JBL-like punch, assuming proper placement in the room?

The JBL will have more lower bass output on its own. the Tobian will have more finesse and texture where you can hear further into the most nuance changes.

Full disclosure: I am obsessive about tweaks in my system with vibration control et al. So to be fair I've set the speakers up to give them their greatest chance to be magical.

If you want a system that is easier to set up and not want to dial in the last 10%, the JBL's will likely be the better choice.

I love JBL so I am not putting them down.

You need to decide if you want - and will set up for MAGIC (Tobian), or VERY GOOD (JBL). Sometimes the JBL's are a bit too tied to the studio monitor mentality towards sound and can lack that last bit of emotion.

Having said that I would take JBL over so many other speakers.

Just trying to be completely honest so you can decide what is best for you. But there is literally no currently produced speaker at ANY price I would ever trade for my 15FH's.
 
Last edited:
I also wanted to add to my post from a few minutes ago the Tobians are much easier to live with than other speakers as they like being closer to the back wall. You don't need them far into the room. So in that regard they are much easier to live with than other speakers.
 
The JBL will have more lower bass output on its own. the Tobian will have more finesse and texture where you can hear further into the most nuance changes.

Full disclosure: I am obsessive about tweaks in my system with vibration control et al. So to be fair I've set the speakers up to give them their greatest chance to be magical.

If you want a system that is easier to set up and not want to dial in the last 10%, the JBL's will likely be the better choice.

I love JBL so I am not putting them down.

You need to decide if you want - and will set up for MAGIC (Tobian), or VERY GOOD (JBL). Sometimes the JBL's are a bit too tied to the studio monitor mentality towards sound and can lack that last bit of emotion.

Having said that I would take JBL over so many other speakers.

Just trying to be completely honest so you can decide what is best for you.
I really appreciate your insight. You get it.
 
I always loved the L300s.

I really like what I’ve heard from the Tobians. I’ve only heard them at shows tho. I have a pair of Rival SEs and love them.

You really can’t go wrong with either of those. Which one would work better in your room is the question.
 
Last edited:
Do you want musical and finesse or something that gives you the room shaking / gut punch you want? My sense is that they are mutually exclusive. Maybe Michael can provide input but my guess is that your sonic priorities do not match his.

Visit Mike or Michael to hear the Tobians. If you don't like, have you considered adding two subwoofers to your existing set up (or similar equivalent) to provide the elevated room energizing / mid bass gut punch you desire? Subs (properly placed and adjusted) can definitely provide that physical sensation. Good luck.
 
Last edited:
Do you want musical and finesse or something that gives you the room shaking / gut punch you want? My sense is that they are mutually exclusive. Maybe Michael can provide input but my guess is that your sonic priorities do not match his.

Visit Mike or Michael to hear the Tobians. If you don't like, have you considered adding two subwoofers to your existing set up (or similar equivalent) to provide the elevated room energizing / mid bass gut punch you desire? Subs (properly placed and adjusted) can definitely provide that physical sensation. Good luck.
Thanks for your input.

I have sub-bass covered by multiple (4) Perlisten subwoofers - two in the front, and two in the back. They contribute well to the sub-bass frequency regions. My attention is more toward the 60-250 Hz range. My Audio Physic Cardeas deliver plenty of harmonic detail in that range, but little visceral energy.
 
Do you want musical and finesse or something that gives you the room shaking / gut punch you want? My sense is that they are mutually exclusive. Maybe Michael can provide input but my guess is that your sonic priorities do not match his.

Visit Mike or Michael to hear the Tobians. If you don't like, have you considered adding two subwoofers to your existing set up (or similar equivalent) to provide the elevated room energizing / mid bass gut punch you desire? Subs (properly placed and adjusted) can definitely provide that physical sensation. Good luck.

"Do you want musical and finesse or something that gives you the room shaking / gut punch you want? My sense is that they are mutually exclusive."

They are not mutually exclusive.
 
Thanks for your input.

I have sub-bass covered by multiple (4) Perlisten subwoofers - two in the front, and two in the back. They contribute well to the sub-bass frequency regions. My attention is more toward the 60-250 Hz range. My Audio Physic Cardeas deliver plenty of harmonic detail in that range, but little visceral energy.
With four subs, you’re well covered.
 
I always loved the L300s.

The really like what I’ve heard from the Tobians. I’ve only heard them at shows. I have a pair of Rival SEs and love them.

You really can’t go wrong with either of those. Which one would work better in your room is the question.
Nice to see an endorsement of the Volti Rival.
 
Back
Top