BendingWave
Well-known member
- Thread Author
- #1
|
|
The Gobel/EMM room was superb-did everything right. For me, Gobel, Avantgarde, Zellaton, Arretai were right at the top, but lots of good rooms.![]()
CAF Show Report: Loudspeakers $50k and Up
This past November marked the first time I’ve attended the Capital Audiofest in Rockville, Maryland (just outside DC). Although several friends had sungwww.theabsolutesound.com
thank you for the kind words. We did try to get the best result possible within the time and space limits. Great team we have btw.The Gobel/EMM room was superb-did everything right. For me, Gobel, Avantgarde, Zellaton, Arretai were right at the top, but lots of good rooms.
Interesting. A guy I know says the industry is moving towards active speakers. I have not seen or heard much. So Rockport is a player. Anyone else>I'm thinking about buying the Rockhopper active bookshelf speakers for my daughter. Good sound-good value at $3800, and really well designed by a MIT acoustic engineer. Built in amps and dsp. Trying to get daughter beyond the bluetooth speaker.
I keep hearing the Perfect 8 were good.I was there Friday and Saturday. The crowds were quite low on Friday and just marginally better on Saturday. Good for the attendees I suppose, but maybe not as great as hoped for the vendors. For me the top rooms were:
1. YG Vesper with Vinni Rossi and MSB Palisade. It was a small system that had incredible imaging and made the room feel maybe 3 times larger than it was. 1a. The second room with the YG XV Studios and MSB Cascade was also excellent but not as stellar as I expected. I have a YG system and those guys are my buds, so factor that in.
2. EMM Labs and Gobel. While I am not a fan of the looks of the Gobel speakers, one cannot deny the incredible sound they produced. Surprisingly coherent for a large speaker and almost near field listening in the front row. I actually found the second row to be best, but it was quite good from multiple positions. I noticed significant toe-in - maybe to produce a more even listening zone. Perhaps the thing I most appreciated about this room was the fairly regular 'presentations' by the crew. I'm a friend of Amadeus and always like his stories. Elliot will help you learn to listen for certain characteristics. He played an imaging demo as well as a track with a solo guitar and upright bass to highlight realistic image size. Bravo on that! I'd call it the most professional room at the show. And the volume level was perfect!!
3. Treble-Clef. I love the look and the sound was excellent! Probably would not buy them due to the active nature, but as a lifestyle piece they are impressive.
4. Perfect8. These were next to the EMM/Gobel room. They were showing a new speaker in a glass enclosure. Mostly open baffle and unique bass arrangement. It sounded way better than I would have guessed a glass speaker could.
5. Magico and VAC. The new S7s sounded very impressive in a huge room. The bass was incredible. At one point Val walked in - that seemed awkward. The main owner was upstairs. Chatted with him a bit - there is no love lost there!
There were some other decent rooms, but also a whole lot of poor sounding rooms. Many of them were a top down presentation with really harsh sounding highs and lacking bass foundation.
I was excited to hear the GTT Audio room, but it was very harsh sounding. Tried a couple of times and it was below par both times.
The AvanteGarde room was not great this time. Usually I find them quite enjoyable, but this time they had all the negative attributes one may associate with horns. Angie also likes the volume way too loud. 100db violins beamed directly in your ear is pleasing to no one!
There was a fairly large room with Vandersteen and it was harsh and thin.
MBL had a good sized room with the 101s and Noble line. I've personally owned a near identical system. They had the 101s bi-amped, but they produced almost no bass. I actually told them to check the amps were connected. They assured me they were, but I mean there was 0 bass. They played Dylan's Man in the Long Black Coat. You could barely hear the bass line.
active speakers have been around since I started in audio btw. I am not sure why they are not more successful and available as they are a simple, mostly complete package for people to buy and use. One would think they would be more popular with the public for the elimination of wires and many boxes but so far that really has not been the case.Interesting. A guy I know says the industry is moving towards active speakers. I have not seen or heard much. So Rockport is a player. Anyone else>
Not quite... I'm quite excited for the advantages that active speakers can bring. We looked at the Treble Clef's quite seriously for a second room. The reasons for my comment include:I keep hearing the Perfect 8 were good.
I also noted the industry is possibly moving towards active. You note the Treble-Clef sound good, but then say you would not buy a good sounding stereo because you don't need amps, a preamp, a DAC. You basically don't need to spend much money to get a really good sounding system. And it can be tuned to work in most any room. But sonic performance is not what your purchasing a stereo for. Is that about right?
I know I am being a toxic butthole. I am attempting to be tongue in cheek. I myself have a hard time getting over, do I want a active analog crossover for my multi amped system. Or do I want a Objectively better system using a active crossover that also eliminated the preamp and DAC. Basically a significantly less expensive system that objectively measures much better and integrates into a room better. I think I have been around the vinyl vs Digital debate for too long and its toxic nature has entered my psyche.
That's a valuable perspective. I think that if you are a careful shopper more money can usually-not always-get more performance. I thought that most of the best shows at CAF were, not surprisingly, quite expensive. I've also come to believe that once you reach a certain point, a little better technical performance doesn't necessarily translate to significantly more joy from listening to the music, which should be the ultimate measure.I believe I personally have been heavily influenced by forum chatter and reviews.. Even interactions and conversations with other audiophile. I believe audio files have been led to believe that the best performance is from separates.
Even if it is possible that the very highest level is found by separates, i'm of the belief a very, very small percentage of us have enough funds to reach for this kind of performance.
The vast majority of us, would be much further ahead, spending less, and using an active system. We would have better sounding system. Eapecially talking setup and integration into account.
My Oprinion.
I walked away from AxPONA with the thought that active speakers are coming forward. The Dutch & Dutch, YG(?) and Devialet demos proved that. They all sounded great and I made a mental note for the future.Interesting. A guy I know says the industry is moving towards active speakers. I have not seen or heard much. So Rockport is a player. Anyone else>