Anybody willing to share a GOOD Meatball recipe?

MikeCh

Active member
Joined
Nov 25, 2013
Messages
1,961
Location
Colorado
I recall an old girlfriend who's father had us over for a pasta dinner that included his homemade meatballs. Man were they good! The only thing I remember as a standout to the recipe is that he boiled them.

We've been wanting to make our own lately, so I ask....is anyone willing to share their favorite Meatball recipe?

If this post gets ZERO responses, I completely understand as many don't want to or can't share their recipes under sworn oath. E.g., my green chile recipe is MINE MINE MINE!!!! :evil:
 
Why don't you ask him If you liked it so much ? I usually buy them from Ikea's Swedish meat balls - too lazy lol
 
Why don't you ask him If you liked it so much ? I usually buy them from Ikea's Swedish meat balls - too lazy lol

Dear Paul,

I think you missed the past-tense part: "I recall an old girlfriend who's father had us over for a pasta dinner" :)

That was twenty some years ago!...otherwise, I would.
 
I recall an old girlfriend who's father had us over for a pasta dinner that included his homemade meatballs. Man were they good! The only thing I remember as a standout to the recipe is that he boiled them.. . .

Boiled them in what?

Usually they would be fried, baked or broiled, then cooked in the sauce for a couple of hours, then kept overnight. That sort of thing is always better the next day.
 
Nothing fancy because it's just a meatball, but this is how I do it

Depending on size of batch, we usually do 3-4lbs of lean ground meat and 3lbs of hot and sweet sausage in our sauce.

Ground Meat
Oregano-Basil-Parsly
Sesame Seeds
Egg
Bread Crumbs
(anything else you like in there)

I make mine more square than round because its hard to fry all sides of a round ball
Fry in a combo of Peanut oil and my wifes Infused Olive Oil until brown on all sides

Then they get cooked for 2 more hours in our sauce.
 
Interesting topic as I've set a goal lately to perfect my recipe. Here's my current recipe...

Equal parts ground beef and ground pork
Fresh Italian parsley, chopped fine
Chopped garlic
Garlic salt or plain salt
Egg
Bread crumbs
Shallot
Grated parmigiano reggiano

I fry them on all sides in a pan with a little oil and then finish in a sauce for as much time as I have left. :)
 
meatballs can be made with any ground meat, beef,veal, pork ,turkey, etc. most people use a mix of say beef pork and veal.
i make mine with straight beef. the idea is to change the consistency so its not just a wod of meat. lol. so you add eggs and breadcrumbs and grated cheese to the meat, eggs thin it out the breadcrumbs/grated cheese thicken it back up , so you can form a ball without it sagging or flatening out when you cook it. once you have a good consistency, add a finely diced onion, chopped garlic(not the overly strong crap thats already chopped in oil), i use fresh oregano and basil(dry is ok but the flavor pops when using fresh) little onion powder and salt and pepper and more grated cheese(never have too much). thats a basic italian meatball. now you can add things too it. i add a little fennel seed for a different flavor, my grandmother added yellow raisins(weird but good). or anything else that is not gross.lol.
cooking them is easy cause you can do it anyway youd like. i usually make 40lbs at a time. so i use a glass 4oz monkey dish to portion them all the same size. i bake mine on sheet pans until 140 degrees(pushing medium well)in the middle , but if i only had to do a few i would brown them in a pan with hot olive oil and let them cook the rest of the way in the sauce.
yes you can boil them but dont, that fat from the beef is part of the flavor, that you will boil away. bolng will dry it out and you will not get a good seared flavor from the outside. that you would with pan frying them.
good luck. unfortunately(for me) this is what i do, any questions just ask.
oh btw about 15 years ago in my younger chef days this receipe with the fennel seed won first place in a meatball cookoff competition.
5 lbs ground beef
2 cups grated chz
1 cup breadcrumbs
6 eggs
1 lg yellow onion diced
1/4c garlic chopped
3 tbl onion powder
3 tbl oregano
3 tbl basil
3 tbl fennel seed
s &p
 
OK guys, a "recipe" without quantities or cooking times is just a list of ingredients, NOT a recipe.
 
OK guys, a "recipe" without quantities or cooking times is just a list of ingredients, NOT a recipe.

This isn't rocket science, it's just a meatball. How can I tell how hot your stove gets or if you fry in cast iron pans to be able to tell you how many minutes to fry the meatball on each side. It's all to taste and desired doneness.

I always thought it was odd that people can't cook something unless they exactly follow a blueprint for simple things like this.
 
I always thought it was odd that people can't cook something unless they exactly follow a blueprint for simple things like this.

i love my wife, but if truth be told her dream house does't even have a kitchen! For dinner, she makes reservations... all kidding aside, some folks just don't "get" cooking. Even with a blueprint things don't turn out. She's gotten better, but if there is any entertaining to be done, I'll be in the kitchen. Of course, grilling is still predominantly a man's thing. Thank goodness.

(There is probably a femi-nazi out there who would beat me to death with a pair of tongs if she were to read this!)
 
Boiled them in what?

He boiled them in water (not too long as I recall) to begin the cooking of them and to eliminate some of the fat. But, now that I read Steve's note above that boiling will remove not only the fat but some flavor, I'm not sure it would be wise.

After the boiling part, I believe he then pan fried them and added to his sauce to simmer for a couple hours.

I just remember him saying that his "secret" was the boiling part....

Thanks for sharing the ingredients lists guys, and no I don't need exact specifications/measurements as we tend to fudge amounts of things ourselves. However, it's nice to see the unique flavors/ingredients that one might not otherwise think about.
 
Think about it, if you go to Costco, or Sams Club or the Supermarket and buy ready made meatballs, that is all they are....meat rolled into balls with not much else besides fat and lots of bread or filler. No recipe needed.
 
This isn't rocket science, it's just a meatball. How can I tell how hot your stove gets or if you fry in cast iron pans to be able to tell you how many minutes to fry the meatball on each side. It's all to taste and desired doneness.

I always thought it was odd that people can't cook something unless they exactly follow a blueprint for simple things like this.

If it was "just a meatball" many restaurants wouldn't closely guard their secret signature recipes.

I can cook ANYTHING. Cooking is organic chemistry lab done in your kitchen. In order to have repeatability, a key factor in any cooking I do, there must be a protocol or else it comes out a little different every time, which for me is not acceptable. This is especially important with regard to spices.

Don't even try to bake anything without a specific set of ingredients, cooking times, temperatures and volumetric or weight measurements--not if you want it to come out well time after time, that is.
 
Back
Top