256kbps AAC vs 192kbps wma - comparison

ohbythebay

ohbythebay

New member
Joined
Apr 11, 2013
Messages
1,381
Location
Seattle Area
An interesting observation A/B testing

So you guys know I use XBOX music streaming on my tablet into my system (through a DAC)

Recently I posted how I used the (gag, ugg, can't say it) Apple service to "replace" a collection of MP3's I had (128kbps) with 256kbps AAC (Apple's A Clown) format. All kidding aside...I played both and tried some A/B testing

Well, the AAC files sound "dull" in comparison. Flat, no soundstage, like a veil over the files. So I am wondering, is WMA just a better format all around even at the lower bit rate ?

Thoughts on the lossy compression? Seems like the $24 for the year was not such a hot deal since they don't sound much different than my 128kbps MP3's
 
Rob - my honest opinion is that you can't make a silk purse out of a sows ear.

I doubt you will be happy with either format to be honest. Your vinyl probably has set the benchmark so high.

At this stage, you may endure redbook, but certainly not MP3 quality files IMO.

I can't stomach MP3 files.
 
Maybe your system isn't resolving enough to hear the difference. :rolleyes:

But seriously, you're taking a compressed file and making it a little less compressed. Are you really getting additional information or is it just adding 1's and 0's to make up the difference with no change, or a degrade, in the sound quality? If you take an uncompressed file and compress it and then uncompress it again, is it the same as when you started? Hmmm.....
 
Doug, no..it is not using the original MP3's. Apple replaces them with NEW higher bitrate files.

Mike, you may be right. What I am hearing of course does not match my vinyl but I am hearing a difference in two of the same files, two formats, different bit rates but the lower rate WMA sounds better than the higher rate AAC. I was surprised. Well, anyway....LOL

I can't stand MP3's anymore either...I cant believe my DJ friend used to use these. I guess if the speakers are large enough and you play it loud enough...it doesn't matter...LOL
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top