WHISK(e)Y!

I think I nee a qualifier here. When you say "Whiskey" I think of Crown Royal. Bourbon is far different to me, like Bullit and Jack Daniels and such. Scotch is more different stil, and I am definitely not a fan of thatl. I'm also not clear on the difference between Rye and Whiskey.

Can you please differentiate or are you grouping all of this under the header Whiskey?

Whisky or Whiskey is a general term for barrel aged distilled spirits made from grain/corn/malt but not sugarcane (rum) or agave (tequila) or grapes (brandy/cognac). Different countries have different laws that govern what constitutes Whisk(e)y.

In Scotland (where it is spelled without the "e"), there are a ton of rules and laws, but the two types you commonly see are Single Malt and Blended. Blended contains Malt whisky as well as grain whisky. That is stuff like Johnnie Walker. Single Malt contains only malt whisky from a single distillery (Such as Macallan). The age statement (which may or may not be present) pertains to the youngest whisky in the blend. Usually, Scotch Whisky is aged in used barrels from something else, most commonly used Bourbon barrels or Sherry barrels but also sometimes Port or Rum. Sometimes they use a combination of barrels.

In America, there are different types of Whiskey (always with the "e") too. The most common would be Bourbon Whiskey (Bulleit, Buffalo Trace), Tennessee Whiskey (Jack Daniels), and Rye Whiskey (Rittenhouse), again all mandated by law on what it must be composed of and how it is aged. In general, bourbon must be at least 51% corn with the other grains usually a combination of Rye, Wheat, or Barley as the "flavoring grain". It also must be aged in new (unused) charred oak barrels. Minimum aging for bourbon is 4 years and goes up to the 20+ year range. As it stays longer in the barrel, it will get smoother but more oaky flavored. Rye on the other hand, must be at least 51% rye. So there can be a lot of overlap between the flavor of some bourbons and ryes (E.g. you can have a bourbon made from 51% corn and 49% rye and it is a bourbon. If you change it to 49% corn and 51% rye, it is a rye whiskey). On the other hand, you can have a Bourbon with no rye at all in it that uses wheat as the flavoring grain and a 100% rye that only has rye in it and they will taste nothing alike. The exact composition of grains that is used is called the mash bill. Other variables include how much char is placed on the barrel (but it must always be new, unused oak), what type of yeast is used to ferment the grains, the climate and location of where the barrels are aged, as well as the length of aging.

Ireland has similar but different laws. It is more similar to Scotch but generally much smoother/lighter in flavor. Jameson is a popular scotch.

Canadian Whiskey (e.g. Crown Royal and others) have their own sets of laws but are usually a combination of a form of Rye whiskey and a neutral grain spirit (e.g. vodka).

Then there is Japanese Whiskey, Taiwanese Whiskey, Indian Whiskey, Australian, French, Belgian Whiskey all of which have their own rules. Most of these are very, very similar to scotch (meaning they are made based on malted barley) and for a long time were considered inferior, but some of the Japanese (e.g. Yamazaki), Taiwanese (e.g. Kavalan), Indian (e.g. Amrut), and Australian (e.g. Sullivan's Cove) have begun to compete pretty well with Scotch Whiskeys.

So in summary, Whisk(e)y, is a general term with lots of subtypes which is why there is confusion. Its just like amplifiers. Class A, Class AB, Class D, Valve, Solid state. They are all amplifiers but very different in "flavor".
 
Thanks for clearing it up for me. However, I still think of scotch, bourbon, rye and whiskey as separate things, not to be lumped into one category. When you say "whiskey" I definitely exclude scotch from that category, though now, after reading your excellent post, I might include rye and possibly even bourbon in "whiskey". Why? Probably because I can drink each of those but completely detest scotch (single or blended).
 
I need to be posting on this thread ... here is my post from the "Friends of Laphroig" site.


08082016204003.jpg
 
Thought I'd try a few listening to Chris Jones through the Soulution & Marten phase... Biggest worry is the ice keeping up, the rest is neat!
attachment.php
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • 592207_1_9999_v1_m56577569855303705.png
    592207_1_9999_v1_m56577569855303705.png
    243.8 KB · Views: 149
  • 904350_0_9999_v1_m56577569854696465.png
    904350_0_9999_v1_m56577569854696465.png
    389 KB · Views: 146
Thanks for clearing it up for me. However, I still think of scotch, bourbon, rye and whiskey as separate things, not to be lumped into one category. When you say "whiskey" I definitely exclude scotch from that category, though now, after reading your excellent post, I might include rye and possibly even bourbon in "whiskey". Why? Probably because I can drink each of those but completely detest scotch (single or blended).

Bob, if you ever get to Scotland you will quickly find out that Scotch is indeed whisky.......for the most part only us goofy Americans call it 'scotch' !

One other addition to Clint's great explanation, bourbon barrels are used but only one time for bourbon aging, after which the majority get sent to Scotland for their whisky. Bourbon, Port and Sherry are the predominant barrels used in scotch whisky aging.
 
Bob, if you ever get to Scotland you will quickly find out that Scotch is indeed whisky.......for the most part only us goofy Americans call it 'scotch' !

One other addition to Clint's great explanation, bourbon barrels are used but only one time for bourbon aging, after which the majority get sent to Scotland for their whisky. Bourbon, Port and Sherry are the predominant barrels used in scotch whisky aging.

Yep, just like you don't order "French Onion" soup in France... it's Onion soup.
 
www.thewhiskyexchange.com This is good web site to have in your back pocket.
brbon_cro56.jpg
I'm not sure if you are into Rye. This is a very good one. Not expensive. Won whiskey of the year. That's unheard of for Canadian Whiskey.
 
I got lucky coming out of Caymans airport. Picked up duty free a couple of bottles of Johnny Walker Blue $157.50 ea. That was a good bargain. I don't know I would pay regular price. It is but hard to justify at full pop. It is the good.
 
All Bourbon is whiskey, but not all whiskey is Bourbon.:) I'm a Bourbon fan.

Sir, no Bourbon is ever Whisky - it is Whiskey.

Only single malt for me.

Ex-post Correction: The other way around (as now written).

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
From the diccionary:


whiskey | ˈ(h)wiskē |

noun (plural whiskeys)

1 (also whisky) a spirit distilled from malted grain, especially barley or rye.
2 a code word representing the letter W, used in radio communication.

USAGE

Is it whiskey or whisky? Note that the British and Canadian spelling is without the e, so that properly one would write of Scotch whisky and Canadian whisky, but Kentucky bourbon whiskey and Irish whiskey.

ORIGIN
early 18th century: abbreviation of obsolete whiskybae, variant of usquebaugh.
 
By the way, I prefer single malt also, but I wouldn't say no to a good bourbon.
 
From the diccionary:


whiskey | ˈ(h)wiskē |

noun (plural whiskeys)

1 (also whisky) a spirit distilled from malted grain, especially barley or rye.
2 a code word representing the letter W, used in radio communication.

USAGE

Is it whiskey or whisky? Note that the British and Canadian spelling is without the e, so that properly one would write of Scotch whisky and Canadian whisky, but Kentucky bourbon whiskey and Irish whiskey.

ORIGIN
early 18th century: abbreviation of obsolete whiskybae, variant of usquebaugh.

Yes, usquebaugh = the water of life, similar to the French eau de vie.

I don’t know about the Canadians, but the Irish spell it Whiskey as well.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top