MQA Discussion

I can't read 144 pages. Did this get resolved? Hahaaaa

Hey Mike, you should post a couple Quick poles. MQA yes or no. Upsample, yes or no. Maybe a spot to enter the digital setup with the answer. Might be interesting to see if there are trends to equipment and what people think sounds good on it.
 
Who listens to depressing news or sports radio in a car. I just listen to music on long drives. :D

I love to listen to music when I drive my 997 CS, and my 540i (full custom Focal K2 set-up and 2,000 blissful watts). My music tase is very different from my cars to my a/v room. The former is "let's rock on!" to the latter which is more jazz to Americana.
 
I love to listen to music when I drive my 997 CS, and my 540i (full custom Focal K2 set-up and 2,000 blissful watts). My music tase is very different from my cars to my a/v room. The former is "let's rock on!" to the latter which is more jazz to Americana.

P-cars for years were not known for being very advanced from the standpoint of audio systems. I recall having to use a very old iPod stuck in the glove compartment to listen to not very good quality music. I bet that the BMW has a much better sound system.
 
You have to spend quite a few thousand to get the premium sound in any good car. But more important in my mind is not how good is tthe stereo, how damped is the tire hum off the road.
 
You have to spend quite a few thousand to get the premium sound in any good car. But more important in my mind is not how good is tthe stereo, how damped is the tire hum off the road.
Not sure I will be listening to music while driving off a hard road and while driving off the road, you are not going to hear the tire hum anyway. . I'm usually more worried about the sand, rocks, getting stuck, trees etcc. than listening to music :D. Maybe you meant something else. Like tire hum ON the paved road.
 

Thanks for posting. Here is a summary someone wrote on the article:

“Timing is of the essence.

The digitization process results in a mirror image with an inverted sideband beyond the Nyquist point.

This 'negative' image must be filtered out from the reconstructed analog form. Even if it is well beyond the sonic range of human perception.

Having a sampling rate of 44.1KHz limits the waveform maximum frequency to be recorded to half the sampling rate which corresponds to 22.05 KHz maximum.

Way before that point, the ultrasonic sidebands must be filtered out.

Having such a steep 'brickwall' filter causes aberrations to the signal. These are termed ringing or echoes before and after the cutoff point.

Natural echoes occur after a signal. However when converted back from digital to analog via the Digital to Analog Converter (DAC) these ringing echoes also occur symmetrically before the moment the signal pulse happens. This causes a coloration to the reconstructed sound.

This phenomenon can me mitigated by sampling at higher frequencies thus requiring a much 'better sounding' gentle filter for the ultrasonic frequencies components.

Thus timing is everything, in the Universe and also audio.

Takeaway: higher sampling rates sound better, due to the shifting of this Nyquist number way above human hearing bandwidth thus requiring less brickwall filters with a gentler slope to achieve the same results, with better (or less perceptible) audible ringing artifacts.

Excerpt:
In natural sound, echoes always occur after a sound—never before. This pre-echo is therefore unnatural; and while a continuous waveform will be reconstructed correctly, it is possible that the pre-echo might well be heard as a degradation with a discontinuous waveform, such as musical transients (see later).”
 
The end of the article (discussing playback of files encoded with the Ayre ADC) would seem to indicate that as far as sound quality alone is concerned, MQA is unnecessary; correct timing can be preserved through the recording chain without its compression or proprietary processing.
 
The end of the article (discussing playback of files encoded with the Ayre ADC) would seem to indicate that as far as sound quality alone is concerned, MQA is unnecessary; correct timing can be preserved through the recording chain without its compression or proprietary processing.

Correct, but it wasn’t being done effectively until MQA came along.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
It appears to me MQA is a "nice" addition to a already great player. In other words, for someone to say "I have MQA on my $200 DAC and therefore it sounds better than your 44.1 DAC (SOTA DAC) is ludicrous and idiotic. You can perfume on a pig, but it is still.....
 
Give me a good dac, good usb or coax and a good music player, the hell with MQA. It is splitting hairs. Until something comes along that radically improves sound I will not support MQA which is licensed and being shoved down our throats.
 
New MQA Partners:

Astell&Kern is announcing MQA integration for its line of portable players, beginning with the A&ultima SP1000 in mid-October, and coming to other players across the range soon.

The A&ultima SP1000, a high-end portable audio player, earned a ‘CES 2018 Best of Innovation Honoree’ award for Portable Media Player & Accessories.

The EISA award-winning DALI CALLISTO wireless loudspeaker system, in combination with the BluOS plug-in module, now supports playback of MQA music from both streaming services or locally stored files.

Calgary-based EMM Labs is a further new MQA partner and has integrated MQA into its recently launched and much-praised DV2 DAC. The upgrade is expected towards the end of this month.

Other new partner announcements include Audiolab’s 8300CDQ DAC, due to be released late October, and Krell Industries, who will be integrating MQA into its K-300i integrated stereo amplifier later this year.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
New MQA Partners:

Astell&Kern is announcing MQA integration for its line of portable players, beginning with the A&ultima SP1000 in mid-October, and coming to other players across the range soon.

The A&ultima SP1000, a high-end portable audio player, earned a ‘CES 2018 Best of Innovation Honoree’ award for Portable Media Player & Accessories.

The EISA award-winning DALI CALLISTO wireless loudspeaker system, in combination with the BluOS plug-in module, now supports playback of MQA music from both streaming services or locally stored files.

Calgary-based EMM Labs is a further new MQA partner and has integrated MQA into its recently launched and much-praised DV2 DAC. The upgrade is expected towards the end of this month.

Other new partner announcements include Audiolab’s 8300CDQ DAC, due to be released late October, and Krell Industries, who will be integrating MQA into its K-300i integrated stereo amplifier later this year.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Keep the hardware coming. The number of software titles grows each week. Plenty of options in all categories.
 
I’m glad Qobuz is coming to the US. For me, many reasons to prefer Qobuz over Tidal/Mqa.
 
MQA is great for streaming, however, currently I am not interested for a couple reasons. I prefer owning my music not streaming, but more importantly it does not compete with better DSD; 256 and more so 512 are fantastic. I put my T+A against MQA; DSD512/48, wow!
 
Back
Top