I'm leaving high end audio...

Especially after seeing a Facebook post today lecturing audio influencers about financial transparency, even quoting federal law about disclosing relationships with manufacturers, distributors, and sponsors.
Please post.
That same person is a co-owner of a forum that accepts sponsorship money from audio companies, including brands whose products and business interests are discussed and promoted on that very forum and by him.
Will you be sued if you provide details? If not, specifics please.
The sponsorships. The gatekeeping. The egos. The endless drama. The double standards.

They are so mired in it themselves they can't even see how polluted much of it has become.
I asume you refer to WBF. If not, what forum and individuals? Please,provide.details If unable to do so, a very bad look. Innuendo, rumors, personal grudges, etc.

All just my own personal opinions and I'm not accusing nor implying anything illegal or unethical by anyone. Just saying people need to walk their own talk.
Looks like you are on a personal vendetta / mission. Again. Bad look. Why continue if the above is true? Very confused. Best
 
Last edited:
Please post.

Will you be sued if you provide details? If not, specifics please. .

I asume you refer to WBF. If not, what forum and individuals? Please,provide.details If unable to do so, a very bad look. Innuendo, rumors, personal grudges, etc.

Hello! It's on his Facebook page today. I'm trying not to post links that divert people away from this discussion, but PM me and I'll gladly send it to you.

Will I be sued for sharing more information? 😂

Well, let's see...

I'm ALREADY being sued by AXISS Audio, owned by Cliff Duffey, over statements I made concerning reported Soulution issues.

And here's the irony: Some of the people publicly commenting on this controversy and lecturing others about financial transparency are associated with forums that receive sponsorship money from AXISS Audio.

Yet where are their own disclosures of those financial relationships when they're discussing this very controversy?

Apparently, transparency is something everyone ELSE is supposed to practice. 😉

Yet, as I've pointed out before, their own lawsuit filing includes screenshots of people discussing Soulution problems independently of me.

And here's an interesting article from Audiofile describing a Soulution INT330 that reportedly required FIVE REPAIRS, including another failure within a WEEK of being sold!

https://audiofile.nl/the-story-of-the-soulution-int330/

I didn't write that article. I didn't experience those failures. I'm simply pointing readers to someone else's published account.

And don't forget, there have also been public acknowledgments of problems involving Soulution equipment.

Then there's the screenshot I'm attaching from someone who identifies himself as a former Soulution dealer, describing his own experiences with the brand.

So let me get this straight.

Other people publicly discuss Soulution reliability problems. A dealer publishes an account of five repairs. A former dealer shares his experiences.

And I'm the one being sued over my statements about reported issues?

You can certainly sue someone for what they say. Whether the allegations are justified is an entirely different question.

That's what makes this whole situation so remarkable to me.

And apparently, asking questions and sharing publicly available information now comes with the added excitement of wondering whether another lawsuit is around the corner. 😂

I'd love to see Cliff Duffey sue this guy now as well, along with all the people he quoted in his own filing who contradicted his claims.

I go over some of his contradictions in his own claims here:







Soulution 330 Terry Repairs.png
 
But here's the problem with your assumption.

Simply identifying sponsors on a page doesn't necessarily tell readers the full nature of the financial relationships or what those sponsorship dollars buy.

Does sponsorship include paid posting to generate the appearance of interest in a product? Special treatment of threads? Promotional activity beyond clearly labeled advertising?

And what about the people running the forum? Have any received free or discounted equipment, or other benefits, from brands whose products they publicly discuss or promote? Are the owners compensated for the threads they start talking about gear in their home?

How about when the owners then move to social media and post in defense of there sponsors with no disclosure on those posts or videos they are receiving money or other from the company?

And are you sure ALL the people paying to be able to post are disclosed?

Do you know the answers to any of those questions?


Because if you don't, how can you honestly and thoughtfully conclude that the disclosures are complete?

I'm not suggesting anything illegal has occurred. I'm asking reasonable questions about transparency, especially when people associated with a commercially sponsored forum are publicly lecturing others about disclosure.

Transparency should work both ways, shouldn't it?

And respectfully, assuming everything has been disclosed simply because there's a sponsor which is assumed to be complete list seems a little...well.....

And here's the good news. My attorneys intend to pursue relevant communications, contracts, financial relationships, and other records through the legal process.

So rather than speculate about what these sponsorship arrangements involve, we may have an opportunity to examine the actual documents and establish the facts.

Transparency is a wonderful thing, isn't it? 😉
You may have missed that I wrote “
But here's the problem with your assumption.

Simply identifying sponsors on a page doesn't necessarily tell readers the full nature of the financial relationships or what those sponsorship dollars buy.

Does sponsorship include paid posting to generate the appearance of interest in a product? Special treatment of threads? Promotional activity beyond clearly labeled advertising?

And what about the people running the forum? Have any received free or discounted equipment, or other benefits, from brands whose products they publicly discuss or promote? Are the owners compensated for the threads they start talking about gear in their home?

How about when the owners then move to social media and post in defense of there sponsors with no disclosure on those posts or videos they are receiving money or other from the company?

And are you sure ALL the people paying to be able to post are disclosed?

Do you know the answers to any of those questions?


Because if you don't, how can you honestly and thoughtfully conclude that the disclosures are complete?

I'm not suggesting anything illegal has occurred. I'm asking reasonable questions about transparency, especially when people associated with a commercially sponsored forum are publicly lecturing others about disclosure.

Transparency should work both ways, shouldn't it?

And respectfully, assuming everything has been disclosed simply because there's a sponsor which is assumed to be complete list seems a little...well.....

And here's the good news. My attorneys intend to pursue relevant communications, contracts, financial relationships, and other records through the legal process.

So rather than speculate about what these sponsorship arrangements involve, we may have an opportunity to examine the actual documents and establish the facts.

Transparency is a wonderful thing, isn't it? 😉
You may have missed that I wrote “If That’s a full disclosure.” As i made clear, I have no way to know. For me, if I know that Joe’s Amps gave a reviewer a free trip to Europe to do a factory tour and a review, I dont need to know the price of an airline ticket-I know enough to know thats its not necessarily an arms length relationship. Just an example. That’s enough for me, but others may think a different standard is appropriate, and thats fine.

As to litigation-obviously financial relationships are fair game for parties and witnesses. The thing about lawsuits- not yours in particular, but any lawsuit- is that parties on every side make lots of claims and assertions. Doesn’t tell you much of anything about what is true or not. You start to get to the truth when documents get produced and people testify under oath. Best for intersted observers to keep an open mind.

I don’t think what we are saying is that much different. If someone is attempting to influence market behavior and the influencer has a financial interest in the product it should be clearly disclosed.
 
You may have missed that I wrote “

You may have missed that I wrote “If That’s a full disclosure.” As i made clear, I have no way to know. For me, if I know that Joe’s Amps gave a reviewer a free trip to Europe to do a factory tour and a review, I dont need to know the price of an airline ticket-I know enough to know thats its not necessarily an arms length relationship. Just an example. That’s enough for me, but others may think a different standard is appropriate, and thats fine.

As to litigation-obviously financial relationships are fair game for parties and witnesses. The thing about lawsuits- not yours in particular, but any lawsuit- is that parties on every side make lots of claims and assertions. Doesn’t tell you much of anything about what is true or not. You start to get to the truth when documents get produced and people testify under oath. Best for intersted observers to keep an open mind.

I don’t think what we are saying is that much different. If someone is attempting to influence market behavior and the influencer has a financial interest in the product it should be clearly disclosed.


You're right and I did miss that in your post. My apologies.

I agree we are on the same page.
 
No problem, and I’m not trying to be combative.. I give them credit for listing their sponsors, but if there’s a lot of undisclosed stuff, that’s not right in any respect.

Thanks for clarifying, and just to confirm I'm not taking your comments as combative at all. I genuinely appreciate the open chat.

Honestly, the absurdity of this entire situation and the enormous emotional toll it's taken on me and my family have been a LOT to deal with.

I think the contradictions I've highlighted from their own filing on my FB page speak for themselves.

My solace comes from knowing we're taking all legal steps to defend ourselves, establish the facts, and seek FULL accountability through the appropriate legal processes.

I look forward to the truth coming out. I believe it will be eye-opening for many in this industry.

And when my family's well-being is affected, I will stand up for them through every lawful avenue available. That's why I've engaged multiple attorneys.
 
Lots of drama. Sorry you are going through this. I do admire your tenacity but, knowing what you know now, would you do it again? I am familiar with Axxis Audio and the connecion to a well known forum persona. Just don't fall on your sword. Best.

That's a great question.

I wish I could say I actually did something wrong. Then there would be something I could say I'd do differently.

But if any of us can be sued simply for discussing issues that a manufacturer has itself acknowledged, and that others were already publicly talking about, then we're ALL in trouble.

I'll only say this: We believe the evidence contradicting their allegations is so strong that it gives us options to pursue legal and financial accountability.

I wouldn't be pursuing those options if I didn't have confidence in the overwhelming evidence supporting our position. I believe some people are going to look very, very foolish when the facts come out.

This kind of behavior should never become acceptable in our society.

Nobody should have to fear a lawsuit simply for honestly discussing their experiences or concerns about audio equipment.

Most adults would pick up the phone first and try to talk through a perceived issue.

But as I've learned, not everyone does.
 
Im just suggesting that the forum experience might be better with a little more civility. Particularly for newcomers. Nothing more than that.

Not trying to trigger your anger. You are free to disagree, and it seems that you do. As I said, I realize that hoping for civility on the internet is a lost cause.

The problem with ASR, there is no discussion about what you hear. Measurements rule there period. You bring up about what you hear and you are ridiculed and eventually booted if you disagree.
 
Not that it matters anymore but why didn't Soulution simply replace the defective, repaired unit? Or did that specfic model have a major design issue and universally defective? Very strange.
 
Last edited:
Not that it matters anymore but why didn't Soulution simply replace the defective, repaired unit? Or was that model simply poorly designed and universally defective?

I think the bigger question is this:

  • When you look at what Terry Baxter, who identifies himself as a former Soulution dealer, posted about reportedly having problems with EVERY 300-series unit he sold;
  • When you read the article from the Netherlands describing one Soulution unit requiring FIVE repairs, along with the author's claims about how Soulution treated him;
  • When you read the WBF posts from owners reporting that attempted fixes didn't resolve their problems;
  • When you read Cyril's comments on WBF suggesting the 717 may have been released before it was ready;
  • And when you look at the numerous reports of Soulution problems referenced in AXISS Audio's OWN LAWSUIT FILING...
How can Cliff Duffey seriously argue that MY discussions of Soulution reliability issues damaged his sales or the brand's reputation when these issues had already been publicly discussed for YEARS?

These issues were being reported by owners and dealers independently of me long before my comments.

That's the question I'd certainly like to see answered.

And here's where things could get VERY interesting.

Through the legal process, we intend to seek relevant Soulution repair and service records to establish the facts. We also intend to speak with affected customers and dealers, where legally permitted, to better understand what actually happened.

How many units experienced problems? How many required repeated repairs? Were potentially reportable electrical or safety issues disclosed to the appropriate authorities when required? Were customers charged for repairs? How long were owners without their equipment?

One person even claimed to have been without their unit for TWO YEARS!

These are legitimate questions, and the actual records may help answer them.

I look forward to establishing the facts and sharing whatever we're legally permitted to make public. And make no mistake, our preference is FULL transparency. If legally permitted, we intend to make the evidence public so everyone can see the facts and judge for themselves.
 
I have been seeing social media posts from CAF. I didn't realize there were so many speakers over $100k now. Is that the new target price point? Most everything I saw was well over 5 figures. The one more budget minded product were the Chesky speakers. And he used Benchmark. I'm sure there were probably other more affordable gear there but that's not what's getting the press this year so far. I've sort of been defending the industry in this thread and stand by my comments but I do see the other side more clearly.
 
Looks like you are on a personal vendetta / mission. Again. Bad look. Why continue if the above is true? Very confused. Best

Hi Gordon,

I realized I missed your last point and wanted to address it so you don't think I'm ignoring you.

Am I hurt? Yes. Am I upset they're attacking us like this? Of course. Do I want to expose the facts while they continue pursuing this? ABSOLUTELY.

But here's the difference between defending yourself and pursuing a personal vendetta.

The day this matter is legally resolved and we've pursued the accountability we believe is warranted, I'm DONE. Emotionally and otherwise. I have far better things to do with my life.

But they continue to file what I consider B.S. claims, including just the other day, and I still haven't seen evidence that convinces me their allegations are justified.

I don't hate these people. I don't wish them ill will. I'm not obsessed with them, and I certainly don't stalk them.

I'm defending myself and my family against allegations they chose to make public. And there's an important distinction between filing a lawsuit and actively publicizing it. In my view, they launched a PR offensive within minutes of filing rather than simply letting the courts handle the matter.

And when I see what I believe are serious contradictions in those allegations, I think it's perfectly reasonable to share the facts and keep people informed.

I'd argue the real question is why this needed to become a lawsuit in the first place rather than a conversation between adults.

And frankly, when companies blame people discussing reported product problems instead of addressing the underlying customer concerns, I think THAT deserves scrutiny.

Yes, I agree this entire situation is a terrible look.

I believe it was completely unnecessary, and I've been deeply disappointed by how it has played out publicly.

But standing up for yourself and your family isn't a vendetta.

It's defending yourself.

Hope that helps explain where I'm coming from and I always appreciate your thoughts and questions.
 
I didn't realize there were so many speakers over $100k now. Is that the new target price point? Most everything I saw was well over 5 figures.
And I suspect this five and six figure price tag will continue until the market determines how much they can push the"bubble", still sell product and make a profit.
e but that's not what's getting the press this year so far. I've sort of been defending the industry in this thread and stand by my comments but I do see the other side more clearly.
The high priced stuff always demands the majority of press. And that will be the death knoll for reasonably priced, good sounding gear.
 
Last edited:
Yes it does. Thank you. And if the courts find the plaintiff guilty and you prevail, what does victory look like? Best. Gordon

Another great question.

For me, victory isn't simply winning in court, getting them to drop the case or collecting a check. It's about clearing my name, protecting my family, exposing what really happened, and holding those responsible FULLY accountable.

This cannot be permitted to happen again to someone else.

My personal definition of victory would include:

  1. Complete vindication. A written apology acknowledging that the accusations against me were false and publicly clearing my name.
  2. An apology to my family. Especially my wife and my 85-year-old father-in-law, who is recovering from a stroke. They've been put through tremendous emotional stress over something they had absolutely nothing to do with.
  3. Full disclosure of communications. I want to know whether individuals or organizations outside AXISS were involved in coordinating or amplifying public attacks against us. If the evidence establishes wrongdoing, I want those responsible held legally and financially accountable.
  4. Follow the money. Were any individuals, forums, or third parties compensated, directly or indirectly, to participate in or amplify attacks against us? If so, who paid whom, how much, and for what?
  5. Answers about WBF. Were there any financial arrangements or communications involving AXISS and WBF related to hosting and prominently displaying the accusations against us while preventing us from responding? I want those questions answered with actual records, not speculation.
  6. Full financial recovery. Reimbursement of 100% of my legal expenses, along with whatever additional damages the evidence and law justify.
And there's one more important point.

Without getting into privileged discussions or revealing our legal strategy, I will say this: We believe there are serious questions about what the plaintiff knew, when they knew it, and what evidence was available to them before making these accusations.

If the evidence establishes that they possessed information contradicting their allegations before pursuing this lawsuit, that would be extraordinarily significant.

I don't just want to win. I want the truth established, my reputation restored, my family vindicated, and those responsible for any proven wrongdoing held accountable.

I believe this entire legal action against us was extreme, unnecessary, and completely unwarranted. None of this needed to happen, yet here we are, spending our hard-earned money defending ourselves while my family deals with the emotional toll.

I should not have my 85 year old father in law trying to recover from a stroke asking me "If Cliff Duffey has decided to do the right thing yet".

No amount of money can give us back the time, peace, and emotional energy this has taken from us. Especially at a time when our family should be focused on helping my father-in-law recover from his stroke, not worrying about a lawsuit.

That's what bothers me the most.

At the end of the day, I want my name cleared, my family's peace restored, and accountability for what we've been put through.

Because winning a lawsuit is one thing. Making things right is another.

No one should have to go through what we have. No one.
 
Back
Top