No one said that an audio dealer can't do well. Where did you get that out of my post? I basically said that the mark up is not as high as some tend to think. And also, this day and age the only place you find high end audio dealers are large cities. Without those numbers of potential clients they really cannot survive. Back in the day there were dealers in many smaller mid-size towns, that is rare now. I have to drive to either LA or SF to find a dealer to actually look at or listen to gear.
So for many of us, there really is almost no opportunity to actually listen and compare without going on a road trip. Do you really think a dealer would consider an in home audition to a potential customer who lives 5 hours away? Unless they have a very established relationship there is no way that would even be considered.
High End Audio is a very niche market. Very small segment of the population has the disposable income or the understanding and passion for music and shiny audio gear to spend as much as a luxury automobile or even a starter home in some cases.
Profit margins are a very tricky concept. One can look at a supermarket and think man, they must have a crazy profit margin keeping a large retail store with all the shelves, refrigerators, lights, employees, stock, constant turnover and deliveries that need to be placed back on shelves... NOPE. Supermarkets are running at 3%... VOLUME business.
Car dealers are running at a slightly larger profit margin but they have to also keep a large retail building and a lot operating with all the staff and service, mechanics, sales, managers, etc... Also volume... They need to move a ton of cars each month.
Then there is audio. Audio does not sell in VOLUME unless perhaps you are running a company like SCHIIT AUDIO and selling components starting at $100 and up to a few grand. VOLUME again. SCHIIT AUDIO also sells direct and cut out the dealer all together.
A typical audio salon has to sell enough of the items to keep the lights on and stay above water at the end of the month. That is not difficult to achieve if you are selling speakers and components costing five digits and are enjoying a 40 to 50% markup.
I am very familiar with retail businesses as I have friends who have done many and have participated in many a business myself. Except that I focused on payment from health insurance companies and not the pocket of the customer. Very different model and I was told I would not succeed due to competition from large entities like hospital based systems. WRONG, I exceled at it. Smoked them all is a better word... All boils down to the same old concept, if you have a head on your shoulders and know how to use it, you will find a way to attract and retain a client so they come to you willingly and with a smile, because you have provided a great service.
Audio is a luxury product, it is a fun product, not some necessity item. It should be easy and fun to do business as generally people are looking to purchase a hobby related item, not a medical device or service when they are not feeling well....
If a dealer can't focus on the fact that every customer that walks through the door is a potential long term client and deserves a bit of your attention, make it by appointment only for clients that have already made purchases. I have friends who run their businesses by appointment only and are also making a living.
It is not rocket science... Some people just can't do business no matter what... Times are changing, concepts and business models change all the time. Adapt or fail... Online retail is much more popular these days for many reasons. Brick and mortar audio will go on but it is not surprising to see less and less of them around.
As long as those holding the most discretionary budget in their hands are buying speakers, amps, cables and power conditioners, those would largely be BABY BOOMERS and Gen X's, there is a good chance to succeed with the brick and mortar business model but I don't see that lasting forever. Things are changing fast and away from that model.