Britten's Orchestra

The Absolute Sound

New member
Joined
Apr 19, 2013
Messages
312
<p>
Wayne Garcia lauded the HDCD iteration of this program in Issue 201 for its musical virtues and its exceptional transparency and realism. Reference Recordings has now released the same program as an SACD—the company’s first. Certainly conductor Michael Stern fully comprehends Britten’s orchestral syntax. If the <em>Four Sea Interludes </em>don’t have quite the majesty, urgency, and existential dread of André Previn’s classic EMI account, Stern’s performance of <em>A Young Person’s Guide </em>is as good as any. <em>Sinfonia da requiem </em>is powerfully dramatic and moving, the pacifist message coming through loud and clear. As spectacular as the HDCD encoding is, the SACD is even better. The soundstage is expansive and seamless, with natural depth and air. Tonally, the recording features exceptionally truthful instrumental signatures: you won’t confuse string basses playing high up on the fingerboard with cellos in their baritonal register. Orchestral weight is impressive, with devastating bass drum/timpani strokes at the outset of the <em>Sinfonia</em>. RR’s 5.1 multichannel delivers a room-filling soundfield—yet in surround there’s somehow less evidence of Keith Johnson’s distinctive genius as a recordist (and maybe a little too much direct sound in the rear speakers.) But be it in stereo or surround, find a way to hear this SACD.*</p>



[Source: http://www.theabsolutesound.com/articles/brittens-orchestra/]
 
I found this recording to be disappointment. I have heard many recordings of A Young Person's Guide and I have to admit that the normally magnificent fugue was anything but. The fugue is some of the most sublime music and everyone I know who has heard this recording state the same thing: the fugue is precise, clean and FLAT.....no chills, smiles, tears....

We agree the sound is great and the venue is impressive (can we say great venue for, Mahler's 8th with 500+ singers??) but I would never say the "A Young Person's" is a long ways from the best.....well played and recorded, but not much more.

Cheers,
 
Back
Top