Aretha Franklin. Power, range, passion. Across so many genres.
I disagree with Stevie, Linda R and others. Stevie has a unique voice, but technically speaking, not a lot of range or variety. Similar with Linda, though Linda is better. Her album with Aaron Neville a prime example.
As another top 2, I mean you really are looking at Ella Fitzgerald. Range, control, and power again.
The question becomes, if a voice is instantly recognizable, does that make it good, or are we responding to the flaws, as attractive as they may be? Stevie Nicks voice had an attraction, especially surrounded by Fleetwood Mac. Highly skilled, but a sound sculpted by Lindsey Buckingham in the prime. I loved the sound of Grace Slick, Janis Joplin. Chrissy Hynde. All unique and brought a sound and power. But technically flawed in a way that resonates with the fan base.
I look at greatness this way. Could Aretha mimic Stevie Nicks with the throaty/nasally performance, and could Stevie mimic Aretha on one of her songs. SN limitations would not permit her doing so, but Aretha could find a way to replace Stevie in Fleetwood Mac.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk