Martin-Logan Summit-X fans here ? ...

joeinid

joeinid

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 4, 2013
Messages
18,726
Location
NY
I've been looking at the Summit-X speakers and wonder if anyone can tell me about your experiences with them.

summit_x_nat_cherry_black_alu.jpg
Natural Cherry / Black Aluminum

[h=2]Summit X[/h]
[h=3]Unparalleled Sound Inspired By the CLX[/h] Amazing mid-range clarity and openness inspired by the CLX loudspeaker is only half of the story. Summit X is the first hybrid electrostatic speaker to bring controlled dispersion to low frequencies. Using a precision Vojtko Voiced™ crossover network to apply variable phasing near the crossover point, Summit X's Controlled Dispersion PoweredForce™ technology provides seamless blending with the XStat™ transducer. Four innovative modular feet adjust vertical dispersion over a 12 degree range, while the 25 and 50Hz level controls fine-tune woofer output to provide smooth, clean, and powerful bass throughout the listening environment.

summitx.gif
24–23,000 Hz ±3dB
30°
44" (112cm) line source
XStat™ CLS™ electrostatic transducer
44" × 11.3" (111.8 × 28.7cm)
497 in[SUP]2[/SUP] (3,209 cm[SUP]2[/SUP])
Two 10" (25.4cm) cast basket, high excursion, aluminum cone with extended throw drive assembly, non-resonance asymmetrical chamber format
Woofer: 2 × 200 watts/channel (4 ohms)
91 dB/2.83 volts/meter
4 Ohms, 0.8 at 20kHz. Compatible with 4, 6, or 8 Ohm rated amplifiers.
20‒600 watts per channel
270Hz
Custom-wound audio transformer, air core coils, polypropylene capacitors
±10dB at 25Hz
±10dB at 50Hz
Control knob to adjust illuminated blue hood logo, back control panel lighting & ground effects lighting
Custom 5-way binding posts
Standby: <1W/channel
Max: 350W/channel
75 lbs. (34 kg)
60.9" × 12.7" × 21.3"
(154.8cm × 32.2cm × 54cm)
Specifications are subject to change without notice.

[TD="align: left"] Frequency Response
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Horizontal Dispersion
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Vertical Dispersion
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] High Frequency Transducer
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"]» Panel Dimensions
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"]» Radiating Area
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Low Frequency Transducer
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Amplifier
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Sensitivity
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Impedance
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Recommended Amplifier Power
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Crossover Frequency
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Components
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Audio Controls
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Lighting
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Inputs
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Power Draw
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Weight
[/TD]

[TD="align: left"] Dimensions
[/TD]

[TD="width: 40%, align: left"][/TD]
 
I've had Martin Logan speakers in my room (Vantage) and used to listen to the CLX at my local dealer quite a bit. Probably got the most positive reaction aesthetically from my non audiophile friends and family. I found them really difficult to place and in my room and to my preferences had its strengths and weaknesses. Strength was how the sound just seemed to float in the air, transparency was excellent and imaging superb. Downsides were I could not get the balance right, meaning the bass and sometimes the mid-range seemed detached from the higher frequencies. There was also this slightly artificial quality to the sound. Then again, I heard the same speaker with McIntosh Tube Amps and a lot of these downsides were mitigated. Very fun speaker to listen to.
 
I demo'd a pair of ML's a while back and was pleased with their sound. Pretty fast sounding. Bass was strong too. I would be intrigued to hear what others have to say as well.
 
Joe....It's funny you brought this topic. The Martin Logan was the speakers that I first fell in love so much and got me in to this wonderful hobby about 20 yrs ago but never had a chance to own one yet. I've been thinking to getting one of these for my self as well. however after research I found that the Montis ( one below SummitX) has been good reviews and some people even told me the Montis is better than Summix overall. ( Not sure coz never had a chance to comparison side by side )

If you go to Martin Logan site the Montis has a more information page including more gallery pics and video when the Summit X page has really nothing.

They really shine on mid range and excellent sweet spot.

Good Luck .

martin-logan-montis-003______________0.jpg
 
Thanks Paul. I'll definitely look at them. I have a few other speakers in mind and will be asking opinions as I discover where I am headed. Overall I love the Studio2 and am finally thinking about selling the TAD CR-1 and I am looking for their replacement once my EAR 890/868 and Conrad Johnson GAT/ART gear comes in.
 
One of my local friends here, have the Montis and they sound much better than the summit
only one problem, they go very low, less than 1ohm
You will need Krell or MC to drive them

The sound is one of the best I heard but they need a lot of setup to sound at best
Highly recommend it to check them out

Nelson
 
Joe, I had the Summit X & the Strads at the same time, my vote is don't go it.
 
sharkmouth said:
Joe, I had the Summit X & the Strads at the same time, my vote is don't go it.
Click to expand...

It was a kind of fleeting thought. I had Apogee Duetta II ribbon speakers and think these would be similar.
 
Hey Joe. The Summit X was one of my finalists before I got the Salon2's. I heard them at a local LI dealer. I love panels, and have always had a sweet spot (but not a physical spot, lol) for the first speakers I ever fell in love with: Maggie's (loved both the 3 and 20). I thought the Summits might be my answer, but, although there were certain sonic aspects that were awesome, they just sounded a bit thin in midrange and a bit metallic sounding (in a slightly unnatural way). Enough so that, while I agonized, I just couldn't pull the trigger on them. Still wish I had the room to put in a pair of Maggie's or, better yet, Soundlabs.
 
If properly positioned and excellent upstream equipment synergy, your jaw would drop hearing a world class reference playback performance. If anyone would like, come on over to experience it yourself.
 
Jeffkad said:
Hey Joe. The Summit X was one of my finalists before I got the Salon2's. I heard them at a local LI dealer. I love panels, and have always had a sweet spot (but not a physical spot, lol) for the first speakers I ever fell in love with: Maggie's (loved both the 3 and 20). I thought the Summits might be my answer, but, although there were certain sonic aspects that were awesome, they just sounded a bit thin in midrange and a bit metallic sounding (in a slightly unnatural way). Enough so that, while I agonized, I just couldn't pull the trigger on them. Still wish I had the room to put in a pair of Maggie's or, better yet, Soundlabs.
Click to expand...

Thanks Jeff,

My Revels are wonderful with the CJ gear. I'm still shopping for fun, not because I need a different speaker, I just keep looking.

Audioseduction said:
If properly positioned and excellent upstream equipment synergy, your jaw would drop hearing a world class reference playback performance. If anyone would like, come on over to experience it yourself.
Click to expand...

George,

I forgot you have the Summit X. Very nice!
 
Late post here, but fronted by ARC ref anniversary and constellation centaurs, it's keeping my q3 on the sidelines...haven't heard a cone/box type speaker that outperforms it in the midrange. Simply heavenly.....And with more than adequate bass that blends seamlessly with the esl panels.
 
George, I'm familiar with the sound of the XA SERIES amps, I can just imagine how sublime that pairing with the Summits must sound! How long have you had this set up?
 
Hello, got my new pair of summit X yesterday. Made a nice deal and found a Demopair for a reasonable price.
Now they should replace the old ML quest i had for over 10 years.
Foto (1).JPG
What i did not hear at the Studio of my dealer was that there is a noise hearable after the Summit is active.
To my ears it sounds like a typical fan-noise originating in the bass section. As both loudspeaker have the same phenomenon, i´m sure that this is no failure more of a amplification quality problem.

It is not loud and not very disturbing but as i live in a very quiet environment any noise is detectable.
I could imagine that it could be a reaction to the german 220 volt electricity supply.
So, is there any SummitX owner who recognized the same or found a solution to this problem.

karl
 
audiokarl said:
Hello, got my new pair of summit X yesterday. Made a nice deal and found a Demopair for a reasonable price.
Now they should replace the old ML quest i had for over 10 years.
View attachment 6480
What i did not hear at the Studio of my dealer was that there is a noise hearable after the Summit is active.
To my ears it sounds like a typical fan-noise originating in the bass section. As both loudspeaker have the same phenomenon, i´m sure that this is no failure more of a amplification quality problem.

It is not loud and not very disturbing but as i live in a very quiet environment any noise is detectable.
I could imagine that it could be a reaction to the german 220 volt electricity supply.
So, is there any SummitX owner who recognized the same or found a solution to this problem.

karl
Click to expand...

Mine have no such noise.
 
Myles B. Astor said:
Mine have no such noise.
Click to expand...
Thank you,
This is what i was trying to find out. Maybe just the european transformer version of the SummitX might have that problem.
But a transformer problem normally result in a kind of hum.

I remember my old old sony TA-E9000ES preamp.
This was one of the early 5.1 surround which had a highclass stereo section inside. If this thing switched to DSP controlled 5.1 a typical noise occurred.
Reason was the low quality DSP chip, at that time one of the best!

Hopefully there are more SummitX owners connected.:skeptical:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top