Aurender W20 vs my hot-rodded PC server

If you have the opportunity to do so you may want to also check out the Lumin U1 which some users prefer to the Aurender N10. Mike sells both lines.

Adam - yup! No surprise. I was like you, CAPS this, CAPS that, tweaking everything, building a killer PC, super MAC mini, etc. I chuckle to myself when these guys think someones home made super-duper PC is better than the Aurender/Lumin U1. Once I heard the Aurender/Lumin U1, it was game over. The other products are dust collectors.

LeRoy (Odyssey) recently did a N10 vs W20 shootout.

Also, make sure you add the Lumin U1 to your audition list if you can.

Well, not all CAPS are beeing eaqual. In fact, the CAPS term may be very misleading, as my computer is radicaly different to a regular CAPS v4 Pipeline, with which it only shared a MoBo, CPU, RAM and case.

All other parts have been replaced, with very substanial SQ gains. I just thought it was enough to eclipse Aurender W20 and similar, but well ... it turned out, I was overly optimistic !

The only two more tweaks I may try with my server is:

- UpTone Audio UltraCap LPS-1 & JS-2 PSUs to supply the Jcat Femto USB card (right now it is still on internal power)
- going to Core Mode

I could also try the HQ Player instead of Jriver.

Elberoth said:

Yesterday, I brought home the Aurender W20 for the first time and ... it sounds better. Damn. A bit fuller in the midrange. Not a night and day difference, but I prefer it over my server.

Now what? I will have to start saving up for the W20. Or the N10, if it is really close in performance.

Click to expand...

Adam.......As soon as I read your thread title, even before clicking on it, I knew the results. If you never experience First Class, you don't miss it. Once you do, there's no going back. I have a sneaking suspicion you knew exactly what was about to happen as your carried the W20 in your front door. Adios CAPS......Hello Aurender.

Elberoth said:

I just thought it was enough to eclipse Aurender W20 and similar, but well ... it turned out, I was overly optimistic !

Click to expand...

I'm not surprised...honestly.

IMO, no guy building a computer in his basement is going to surpass the R&D of what Aurender & Lumin are doing. I also think, if you don't have your own app, you're only half way there.

I keep reading more and more people coming to the same conclusion.

Congrats.

If you're looking at the W20, you may want to also try the Sound Galleries Monaco (SGM2015) server. The SGM is an all-out assault on sound quality and integrates Roon/Tidal and HQPlayer seamlessly.

I would also suggest looking at the Audio Alchemy Digital Media Player (DMP-1). The DMP is a bit-perfect player that punches way above its budget and integrates Tidal/Roon seamlessly.

I own them both. And each can be an excellent match depending on your DAC.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Adam,

I hadn't realized you were the OP!

Hope you are well. It has been quite a journey from the original CAPS route. Technology has moved quickly and in very positive directions.

Best regards,


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

If you are going to check out the W20 then do yourself a favor and also check out the Sound Galleries Monaco, SGM 2015. You will not be sorry.

It is a shame you are not in the New Jersey/NYC metro area. I will be hosting a "demo" of the SGM 2015 on the 11th of Dec. You should contact Ed aka Eurodriver to set up a demo for you.

I know SGM concept well. I've been present on the official press launch event in Munich @ BMW Welt. The problem is, I cannot borrow one locally. With the Aurender, I do not such a problems - all models are just one phone call away - I can have any model next day on my door steps, as the distributor is a good friend of mine.

I also have the SOtM sMs-200 and (malfunctioning) Sonore MicroRendu. I will try them against the Aurender W-20 as well.

Mike said:

I'm not surprised...honestly.

IMO, no guy building a computer in his basement is going to surpass the R&D of what Aurender & Lumin are doing. I also think, if you don't have your own app, you're only half way there.

Click to expand...

It is not exactly the right comparo.

My server is built around parts that have been engineered by others - Intona (Jcat Isolator), Adnaco Technology (Jcat USB Card), Teradak, Bakoon etc - I just put them together.

Elberoth said:

It is not exactly the right comparo.

My server is built around parts that have been engineered by others - Intona (Jcat Isolator), Adnaco Technology (Jcat USB Card), Teradak, Bakoon etc - I just put them together.

Click to expand...

I tried SOTA parts too when I build my various music servers over the years. None of mine could beat the Aurender or Lumin U1 either.

Mike said:

I tried SOTA parts too when I build my various music servers over the years. None of mine could beat the Aurender or Lumin U1 either.

Click to expand...

Couldn't agree more Mike.

I'm willing to sacrifice convenience for improved sound quality, and although each increment in my CAPS journey resulted in not insignificant improvements in sound quality, in the end all of the previous experiments are now on the sidelines.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Elberoth said:

I know SGM concept well. I've been present on the official press launch event in Munich @ BMW Welt. The problem is, I cannot borrow one locally. With the Aurender, I do not such a problems - all models are just one phone call away - I can have any model next day on my door steps, as the distributor is a good friend of mine.

I also have the SOtM sMs-200 and (malfunctioning) Sonore MicroRendu. I will try them against the Aurender W-20 as well.

Click to expand...

Too bad.

Other than the SGM I am sure the W20 will beat the others sound quality wise.

I have gone through possibly all things and within my means that hunched me it would increase the SQ of computer audio - thanks for being a member at CA To name a few - JPlay Dual PC setup with WS 2012R2 and AO in core mode, microRendu, linear power supply, fanless SMPS power supply, battery power to SSD/USB card, PPA motherboard clock upgrade, PPA low noise DDR3 RAM, OCXO and TCXO Clocks, different USB card JCAT/PPA, Industrial Intona, PPA network switch, a bunch of different high $$ ethernet cable, Fiber FMC, Wyred4Sound R2R, Uptone Regen, iFi DC purifier, Bios settings, and a host of different things which I don't even remember. While some added some small increment to the SQ, they either did something bad to other parts of SQ or nothing to home run about.

At one point my music room looked like a lab rather than anything - gazillions of power supply with gazillions of DC and power cables going to different parts of computer/NAS/system. If I turned everything off, I can guarantee nobody, except myself, would be able to get my system up. I found myself more and more everyday tweaking things rather than deeply enjoying music. One which started as a fun project, over time became incredibly complicated and difficult to maintain setup.

Even if you are a system integrator and integrating best of the best parts available off the shelf, you never know how good they work together and this is one of the reason why a DIY products (mostly for folks like us who doesn't have measuring instruments) will never be able to compete with a professional product, like a Lumin or Aurrender. If I look back on all the money spent, I could have gotten a Aurrender N10 or a Lumin A1 and if I had to start over, I would definitely go this route.

Being a happy owner of W20 for several years ( one of the first models with 6TB) I went to Sound Galleries last September for listening session.
My Lampi is 256 fs, first R2R version. Geoffrey Armstrong prepared the setup with T+A 8 Dac , the files were upsampled to 512 fs DSD with HQ Player using Roon.
I was very much impressed by the sound especially transparence, resolution and far from technical very smooth playback.
Now the question arise- was it better than my W20-B7 combo?
The comparo was not side by side and the rest of the setup was different ( altough I know Avantgarde speakers quite well) but I would say that the potential of SGM 2015 is bigger than this one of W20.
If I had no Aurender I would probably go for SGM but the process of copying over 2 TB of files and the price of SGM make the switch questionable.
Moreover last month I am back to sacd played with my La Fontaine and must say that I like very much what I hear.

Well, it seems there is still hope

I added the UpTone Audio JS-2 and UltraCap LPS-1 PSU combo to feed my Jcat Femto USB card (it was powered internally by not-so-clean power from the MoBo before) and now my PC server and Aurender W20 are neck to neck. I have been switching back and forth the whole day, and I cannot say I have a preference for one or the other. They are very, very close. I would not be able to tell them apart in a blind test.

Which is a great sign, as I still have the Core Mode and HQ Player up my sleeve to try (I've been using the Jriver 21 in bitperfect (Bitstreaming) mode playing DSD files vs the Aurender).

But still - if you consider how many boxes I have now (the server itself + 4 (FOUR !) outboard PSUs + Synology 1815plus NAS) - the Aurender W20 is still a great all-in-one solution for those who have the funds and are not into the geek stuff.

Honestly, if you have the money and would rather spend your time listening to music than solving the hardware issues, the Aurender W20 is still way to go.

Adam,

I agree with your assessment of the JS-2. I tried several other LPS, and the Uptone JS-2 was the best amongst the ones I tried by far.

My last CAPS version included the JS-2 powering the MOBO, USB card and internal SSDs that stored the OS and music files in a Computer audiophile/Zalman case; and used WS2012R2, Audiophile Optimizer in ultimate core mode, and JRiver (bit perfect).

This last CAPS version was head and shoulders above any CAPS server configuration I had previously tried in my system.

I did not hear this server against the Aurender lineup, but a trusted colleague tried the same server without the WS2012/AO and JS-2, and in his opinion it was preferred to the W20 (perhaps an earlier version).

My last CAPS version now sits inside a closet. It has been bested by far by both the Audio Alchemy DMP-1 (bit perfect) player (developed by Peter Madnick of Constellation Audio and Audio Alchemy) and the SGM2015/HQPlayer.

Without a doubt, the W20 presents a high performance option for those that have the funds, inclination to spend them, and are looking for a great user-friendly experience.

I would only suggest that those who fit that profile, may also want to consider the SGM2015; and for those willing to spend a lot less cash, the AA DMP-1.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Elberoth / Adam -

I also have a hotrodded CAPS and have been following this thread with interest. I am running the JS-2 for the USB card, and the main power. I have the JCAT USB Femto on order, and plan to power it with LPS-1 when the Femto gets here.

I was surprised to hear you are not running AO in Core mode, because that makes a HUGE difference in my system. To go with your metaphor: it's like the Nitro for the Hotrod! This makes me believe we are not behind in SQ at all!

That being said, things are changing quickly. It is my understanding that integrating Roon, Tidal et Al, isn't currently possible with AO in core mode. And while I have invested a fraction of the cost of a W20, I have a fair amount of tinkering and time in the process, which I enjoy, but the average audiophile would rather plug and play. And also there is not a recipe for the CAPS alternative, so some would never get to that level of SQ.

I will probably build another CAPS hotrod machine for one of my systems, but I will also be keeping a keen eye (and ear) to the price and performance of the new mainstream alternatives.

Randy